Asee peer logo

McMillan Water Treatment Plant DC: embedding culture in civil engineering

Download Paper |

Conference

2021 Fall ASEE Middle Atlantic Section Meeting

Location

Virtually Hosted by the section

Publication Date

November 12, 2021

Start Date

November 12, 2021

End Date

November 13, 2021

Tagged Topic

Diversity

Page Count

7

Permanent URL

https://peer.asee.org/38443

Download Count

13

Request a correction

Paper Authors

biography

W. M. Kim Roddis The George Washington University

visit author page

A registered professional engineer, Professor Kim Roddis has experience in heavy industrial and general commercial building design, as well as in bridge design. She is a structural engineer with varied teaching and research interests, which include: design, fabrication, and construction processes; structural applications of artificial intelligence and computer-aided design; web-enhanced teaching; fatigue and fracture in bridges; frame stability; and seismic steel connections. She is recognized nationally as an expert in distortion-induced fatigue of steel highway bridges and internationally as an expert on the application of artificial intelligence and advanced computing methods to civil engineering problem solving.

visit author page

Download Paper |

Abstract

McMillan Water Treatment Plant DC: embedding culture in civil engineering W. M. Kim Roddis George Washington University Abstract Submission
 The McMillan Water Treatment Plant (WTP) in Washington, DC is a case study in CE 1010 Introduction to Civil and Environmental Engineering. It not only surveys 100 years of urban drinking water technology, but also includes multiple cultural aspects.

Washington, DC has historically been plagued by poor drinking water quality. Union troops stationed In Washington during the Civil War suffered from waterborne diseases. Abraham Lincoln’s son Willie died at age 11 of typhoid fever.

Public health improved with the opening of the original McMillan WTP in 1905. This was a slow sand filter plant, purifying water using physical and biological filtration processes. Such slow sand filters provide potable water without the use of chemicals but are land and labor intensive. The cells for the sand filters covered many acres. Fredrick Law Olmsted designed a 25 acre public park over most of the grid of cells. McMillan Park, opening in 1912, was the only de facto racially integrated park in DC at the time. The park provided a rare opportunity to enjoy this public good for people in the surrounding communities until it was fenced off at the beginning of WWII.
 In 1986, the WTP was decommissioned with the opening of the adjacent rapid sand filter WTP. This technology uses physical and chemical processes to provide potable water. Potomac River water flows from the Great Falls raw water intake and the Little Falls raw water pumping station. Pre-sedimentation occurs at Dalecarlia Reservoir. Fluoride and the coagulant, alum, are added and the water enters the Georgetown Sedimentation Basins. The water flows underground through the Washington City Tunnel to the McMillan Reservoir. Power actuated carbon and chlorine are added and the water flows through the rapid sand filter. Lime, orthophosphate, and chlorine are added and primary disinfection takes place during dwell time in the clearwell. Ammonia is added and the water passes to the storage clearwell. DC WASA Bryant Street Pump Station drives the water to storage tanks from which the water is distributed to consumers in the District of Columbia, Arlington County, and the City of Falls Church.

The McMillan WTP is still in use today. It has been and continues to be upgraded with modern advances in water treatment. One change, made before 2001, had dire unintended consequences. Chemical treatment was changed from chlorine to chloramine. This provided longer term disinfection when water flowed through distribution pipes. Tragically, this also destabilized the pipe chemistry, resulting in harmful lead levels. The problem was fixed in 2004, but thousands of children suffered permanent damage.

With the less land intensive rapid sand filter in place, the 25 acre fenced and closed McMillan park was sold to the government of DC. In 2021, this space remains chained off and idle, with the city unable to formulate a development plan acceptable to the neighborhoods.

My teaching philosophy is to approach engineering problem-solving in a broader societal context. Civil engineering inherently serves society. Selecting case studies that embed significant cultural content into the civil engineering problem statement allows me to emphasize to my students that solving the right problem is as important as solving the problem right.

Roddis, W. M. K. (2021, November), McMillan Water Treatment Plant DC: embedding culture in civil engineering Paper presented at 2021 Fall ASEE Middle Atlantic Section Meeting, Virtually Hosted by the section. https://peer.asee.org/38443

ASEE holds the copyright on this document. It may be read by the public free of charge. Authors may archive their work on personal websites or in institutional repositories with the following citation: © 2021 American Society for Engineering Education. Other scholars may excerpt or quote from these materials with the same citation. When excerpting or quoting from Conference Proceedings, authors should, in addition to noting the ASEE copyright, list all the original authors and their institutions and name the host city of the conference. - Last updated April 1, 2015