Paper Authors

Abstract

NOTE: The first page of text has been automatically extracted and included below in lieu of an abstract

Methods for Assessing the Impact of a Capstone Design Course on Selected Student Traits

Abstract – This paper describes the development of a pilot study to determine the impact of a Capstone Design Course on selected student traits (problem solving, critical thinking, initiative, and transfer) identified by business and industry as necessary for success. Included are a review of the literature, a statement of the research question, the design and methodology of the study, procedures for the study, methods for data analysis, and a summary. The Capstone Design course is a requirement for every Engineering Technology student. The researchers’ goal is to determine whether this course enhances, and to what level, the traits. The researchers use four pre-tests at the beginning of the two-semester Capstone Design course and four post-tests at the end of the Capstone Design course to measure enhancement of the traits. These tests form the basis for pilot test assessment of these traits and will become the foundation for future research conducted within the Schools of Engineering & Technology, Education, and Business. Since these four traits, or qualities, are applicable to all areas of successful job placement and job performance, the post-assessment data, which can be thought of as a summative evaluation, of the students’ growth will yield a formative evaluation of the merits of the Engineering Technology program. After the students are made aware of their individual growth in these traits they will be given an open ended survey to give their opinion on why they made progress. Researchers from the Schools of Education and Business administer the tests to maintain confidentiality of student responses until after the completion of the courses. The objective of the research is to determine which elements of the design course experience have the greatest impact on these traits. Aspects of knowledge important to the enrichment of engineering and engineering technology students include problem solving, critical thinking, initiative, and the transfer of knowledge and skills from introductory instruction to working applications. While information and insights into students’ learning in other disciplines should not be discounted, research that is done with students working toward different degrees and/or problems not specific to engineering students and engineering problems is not well understood (Turns, Atman, Adams, and Barker, 2005)12. Insights into engineering students’ learning inherently need to stem directly from experience in course contexts for maximum applicability to success in the job market. Keywords: Problem Solving, Critical Thinking, Initiative, Transfer, Design, Capstone

Introduction

It is important to evaluate the effects of the Capstone Design course on student traits in the four specified areas to promote course re-evaluation for improved instruction and adherence to ABET standards. The research question for this study was generated through workshop on engineering education research conducted at the Colorado School of Mines in August of 2005. The authors participated through a project funded by the Center for the Advancement of Scholarship on Engineering Education (CASEE) and the National Academy of Engineering (NAE). Although the workshop and the literature focus on engineering education, the authors believe they are also applicable to engineering technology.

• Citation

• Format
  • APA
  • APA - LaTeX bibitem
  • MLA
  • MLA - LaTeX bibitem
  • Bibtex
  • EndNote - RIS

Romine, P., & Gile, W., & scherff, E. (2007, June), Methods For Assessing The Impact Of A Design Course On Selected Student Traits Paper presented at 2007 Annual Conference & Exposition, Honolulu, Hawaii. 10.18260/1-2--2999