Mission Impastable: Using spaghetti bridges to introduce pre-college students to engineering

Claire VerHulst; Karen Borgsmiller

Download Paper | Permalink

Conference: 2020 Mid-Atlantic Spring Conference
Location: Baltimore, Maryland
Publication Date: March 27, 2020
Start Date: March 27, 2020
End Date: March 28, 2020
Page Count: 11
DOI: 10.18260/1-2--33939
Permanent URL: https://peer.asee.org/33939
Download Count: 3898

Paper Authors

biography

Claire VerHulst Johns Hopkins University orcid.org/0000-0003-2974-9405

visit author page

Dr. Claire VerHulst is the Assistant Director of Engineering Innovation, a Johns Hopkins University program designed to introduce high school students to engineering. Claire has a B.S. in mechanical engineering from the University of Notre Dame and a Ph.D. in mechanical engineering from Johns Hopkins University. Her specialty is computational fluid mechanics with applications to wind turbines and gas turbine engines. Prior to joining Engineering Innovation, Claire was an Assistant Professor of Mechanical Engineering at the U.S. Military Academy at West Point.

visit author page

biography

Karen Borgsmiller The Johns Hopkins University

visit author page

Karen McNeal Borgsmiller received her BS in Chemical Engineering from Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute and her PhD in Chemical Engineering from Georgia Institute of Technology. She has been the Director of Engineering Innovation since 2012.

visit author page

Download Paper | Permalink

Abstract

Engineering is often a competition between multidisciplinary teams who use interdisciplinary engineering analysis, simulation, and hands-on construction to address a problem that has multiple valid solutions. It can be a struggle to emulate this environment in the classroom, especially when students have only rudimentary knowledge of engineering subjects. One potential vehicle to introduce students to realistic engineering challenges is a survey course for pre-college or first-year students. In this paper we discuss a pre-college engineering survey course with particular emphasis on its spaghetti bridge competition, a project that introduces students to materials science, statics, error analysis, simulation, engineering design, and gives them experience working on a team.

Every year hundreds of students devote 20 days of their summer break to learn more about engineering. They complete lab activities in civil, chemical, electrical, mechanical, and materials engineering. They also prepare a presentation in response to a request for proposal, learn about engineering finance, debate engineering ethics, take weekly quizzes, and complete a comprehensive final exam. They participate in a course that has served 4,651 students since its inception in 2006 and 1,073 students in the last two years alone. The core project they complete is a competition to build a bridge that can support the largest mid-span load after accounting for weight and size penalties. The bridge must span 50 centimeters, weigh less than 250 grams, and have a height less than 25 centimeters. The strongest bridges often hold more than 40 kilograms, but teams receive full credit for bridges that hold 3 kg. To accomplish this feat, students experimentally determine material properties of spaghetti, use a virtual lab to design a truss, and prototype and build their bridges to test on the final day of the course.

This paper discusses the implementation and outcomes of the spaghetti bridge competition and its role within the pre-college survey course. Based on survey results from an external evaluator, the course significantly increases students’ understanding of the variety of work that engineers perform. Students also report increased confidence in their ability to evaluate problems they have never seen before and design and build a structure without a detailed plan. Importantly, they also report that they are more confident about being in a diverse, multicultural group of people. Overall, the project serves its purpose of introducing students to interdisciplinary engineering concepts.

Citation
Format

VerHulst, C., & Borgsmiller, K. (2020, March), Mission Impastable: Using spaghetti bridges to introduce pre-college students to engineering Paper presented at 2020 Mid-Atlantic Spring Conference, Baltimore, Maryland. 10.18260/1-2--33939

TY - CPAPER
AB - Engineering is often a competition between multidisciplinary teams who use interdisciplinary engineering analysis, simulation, and hands-on construction to address a problem that has multiple valid solutions. It can be a struggle to emulate this environment in the classroom, especially when students have only rudimentary knowledge of engineering subjects. One potential vehicle to introduce students to realistic engineering challenges is a survey course for pre-college or first-year students. In this paper we discuss a pre-college engineering survey course with particular emphasis on its spaghetti bridge competition, a project that introduces students to materials science, statics, error analysis, simulation, engineering design, and gives them experience working on a team.

Every year hundreds of students devote 20 days of their summer break to learn more about engineering. They complete lab activities in civil, chemical, electrical, mechanical, and materials engineering. They also prepare a presentation in response to a request for proposal, learn about engineering finance, debate engineering ethics, take weekly quizzes, and complete a comprehensive final exam. They participate in a course that has served 4,651 students since its inception in 2006 and 1,073 students in the last two years alone. The core project they complete is a competition to build a bridge that can support the largest mid-span load after accounting for weight and size penalties. The bridge must span 50 centimeters, weigh less than 250 grams, and have a height less than 25 centimeters. The strongest bridges often hold more than 40 kilograms, but teams receive full credit for bridges that hold 3 kg. To accomplish this feat, students experimentally determine material properties of spaghetti, use a virtual lab to design a truss, and prototype and build their bridges to test on the final day of the course.

This paper discusses the implementation and outcomes of the spaghetti bridge competition and its role within the pre-college survey course. Based on survey results from an external evaluator, the course significantly increases students’ understanding of the variety of work that engineers perform. Students also report increased confidence in their ability to evaluate problems they have never seen before and design and build a structure without a detailed plan. Importantly, they also report that they are more confident about being in a diverse, multicultural group of people. Overall, the project serves its purpose of introducing students to interdisciplinary engineering concepts.

AU - Claire VerHulst
AU - Karen Borgsmiller
CY - Baltimore, Maryland
DA - 2020/03/27
PB - ASEE Conferences
TI - Mission Impastable: Using spaghetti bridges to introduce pre-college students to engineering
UR - https://peer.asee.org/33939
DO - 10.18260/1-2--33939
ER -