Asee peer logo

Sharpening Statics As A Tool For Design: Demystifying The Modeling Of Forces At Connections

Download Paper |

Conference

2005 Annual Conference

Location

Portland, Oregon

Publication Date

June 12, 2005

Start Date

June 12, 2005

End Date

June 15, 2005

ISSN

2153-5965

Conference Session

Improving Statics Instruction

Page Count

11

Page Numbers

10.1114.1 - 10.1114.11

Permanent URL

https://peer.asee.org/15322

Download Count

40

Request a correction

Paper Authors

author page

Paul S. Steif

author page

Anna Dollar

Download Paper |

Abstract

Statics is an early, critical step in preparing engineers, persons who can bridge the gap between fundamental concepts of physics and the analysis and design of real mechanical and structural systems. Students struggle with many concepts in Statics. We propose here that the modeling of supports, joints or connections between bodies is one of the most difficult and important ideas to be grasped in Statics. Moreover, it is probably at the core of linking physics with real mechanical and structural systems. The notions of force and equilibrium can be dealt with in purely mathematical ways, until one is compelled to associate forces with the actual interactions between particular bodies. Doing that correctly is not easy for students, and yet it is critical. We suspect that continuing difficulties in applying Statics in upper level design courses is at least partially tied to weaknesses in this area. We have previously criticized various aspects of traditional instruction in Statics. The subject of connections, in particular, typically receives cursory treatment in textbooks, as exemplified by the tables showing idealized drawings of joints and the unknown “reactions”. Traditional statics courses and textbooks are essentially teaching the analysis of forces for “pre-modeled”, simplified situations. Moreover, these situations are neatly separated into two- and threedimensional cases often covered in separate chapters. In reality, all mechanical and structural systems are three-dimensional; it is up to the engineer to decide if a two-dimensional analysis is warranted. To its detriment, we believe, traditional instruction in Statics also tends to minimize any reference to motion. Clearly, motion is tacitly present in problems that are often legitimately analyzed using Statics, including, for example, slowly moving mechanisms, and gears and shafts rotating steadily at high speeds. Reference to motion is clearly necessary if we are to explain to students the purpose of many connections: to accommodate certain motions between parts while precluding other motions. Noting the relative motions that are allowed and prohibited is also obviously one way of tracking and rationalizing which reactions can be present in different types of connections. Only if students are familiar with the essential features of connections, we would argue, can they: (i) recognize the various physical realizations of connections, (ii) understand the possible forces acting between connected members, and (iii) model the forces appropriately. With this premise, we propose significant enhancements to instruction pertaining to connections. These enhancements highlight the various roles that connections play in machines and structures, rationalize in a deeper way the relation between possible forces and physical characteristics of connections, and even empower students to draw their own conclusions regarding the virtues of certain designs over others. We fully recognize that most instructors devote relatively modest time to connections, probably referring students to the tables in books. For the reasons suggested above, however, we suggest that mechanics instructors reconsider this allotment of instructional time. To make enhanced attention to practical connections, we have begun to devise appropriate elements of instructional content. This content is suitable for a Statics course, and could allow for the generation of specific educational materials, such as textbooks and in-class instructional materials. In the following sections of the paper we address earlier experiences in our Statics sequence that can prepare students for understanding connections, followed by excerpts from the newly developed content.

Steif, P. S., & Dollar, A. (2005, June), Sharpening Statics As A Tool For Design: Demystifying The Modeling Of Forces At Connections Paper presented at 2005 Annual Conference, Portland, Oregon. https://peer.asee.org/15322

ASEE holds the copyright on this document. It may be read by the public free of charge. Authors may archive their work on personal websites or in institutional repositories with the following citation: © 2005 American Society for Engineering Education. Other scholars may excerpt or quote from these materials with the same citation. When excerpting or quoting from Conference Proceedings, authors should, in addition to noting the ASEE copyright, list all the original authors and their institutions and name the host city of the conference. - Last updated April 1, 2015