Paper ID #16261A Civil Infrastructure System Perspective - Not Just the Built EnvironmentDr. Douglas Schmucker P.E., University of Utah Dr. Schmucker has 20 years experience in teaching and consulting. Focused on high quality teaching following the T4E, ExCEEd, and NETI teaching models, he currently is a full-time teaching professional with a focus on practice, project, and problem-based teaching methodologies.Dr. Joshua Lenart, University of Utah Dr. Joshua Lenart is an Associate Instructor with the Communication, Leadership, Ethics, and Research (CLEAR) Program at the University of Utah where he teaches technical
such as regulatory, economic, environmental, social, political, ethical, health and safety, constructability, and sustainability. (4) Provide a platform where student performance against the ABET general criteria for engineering programs 3 a-k and civil engineering program specific criteria can be assessed.The senior design experience was tailored to ensure coverage of the appropriate programmaterial – items (1) – (3) in the above list suggests this. In some ways, constructing theappropriate assessment vehicle(s) was a more considerable challenge. The open-endednature of realistic design does not always lend itself to concrete assessmentmethodologies. The rest of this paper briefly outlines the UT Tyler CE program
importance of students to understand problems’ andsolutions’ impact across the three pillars of economic growth, environmental stewardship, andsocial progress. The multi-dimensional analysis allows students to better assess the complexityof the application of the knowledge they learn. The concept of sustainability even appears in theCivil Engineering Code of Ethics as one of the Fundamental Cannons that “Engineersshall…strive to comply with the principles of sustainable development…;”15 yet more evidencethat sustainability is becoming a foundational and essential component of an engineeringeducation.Given the importance of sustainability in civil engineering curricula, an important questionremains: how do we teach it? One method discussed in this
bodies. According to ACCE accreditation document 103 retrieved fromhttp://www.acce-hq.org/images/uploads/Doc_103_Updated_081116_final3.pdf, studentsgraduating with a 4-year degree shall be able to create construction project cost estimates as wellas have knowledge on related areas which include 1) ability to analyze professional decisionbased on ethical principles; 2) analyze construction documents; 3) analyze methods, materials,and equipment used to construct projects; 4) understand construction risks; 5) understand thelegal implications of contracts; 6) understand construction project control process; 7) createconstruction project schedules; 8) create written communications appropriate the constructiondiscipline; 10) create oral presentations
]. ASCE points to the uncertain tomorrow where engineersmust work together to create innovative solutions to climate change, technological advances inalternative energy, autonomous vehicles, smart cities, advanced construction techniques andmaterials, and new approaches to governance. These tremendous challenges are not designed,built, operated, and maintained in a vacuum. They require experts from a myriad of disciplines tocollaborate, communicate effectively, and make well-informed, ethical decisions in order to besuccessful. The American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) also recognizes theimportance of collaboration between disciplines as it “promotes the art, science, and practice ofmultidisciplinary engineering and allied sciences
confidence, motivation, expectancy, andanxiety). A confidence interval was derived by bootstrapping the data since normality wasrejected. The PI (Project Impact) items in the survey shown in Table 2, were also averaged andbootstrapped.Table 2. Survey administered to a) senior students upon completion of the capstone project,and b) recent graduates Item Statement/Question Rate how the project affected your ability to (1-No Impact; 3-Moderate Impact 5-High Impact): PIa Apply knowledge of mathematics, science, and engineering PIc Design a system, component, or process to meet desired needs within realistic constraints such as economic, environmental, social, political, ethical, health and safety, manufacturability
students grasp what sustainable design “is” or “should look like.”IntroductionThe first canon of the American Society of Civil Engineers’ code of ethics reminds students,professors, and practicing engineers of the professional responsibility to hold paramount publicsafety and welfare and “strive to comply with the principles of sustainable development in theperformance of their professional duties” [1]. Accordingly, engineering graduates are expected todemonstrate knowledge, skills, and attitudes that will position them to design sustainablesystems. ABET reinforced this expectation with a special issue brief released in November 2018and titled “Sustainable Education: Readying Today’s Higher Ed Students to Tackle the World’sGrand Challenges.” The
and Shells 3 31 16 78 13 66A7. Properties & Behavior of CE Materials 6 66 47 97 23 81A8. Numerical Methods 3 44 13 56 9 66 E. Management and Professional ToolsE1. Design Office Organization/Management/Office Ethics 0 19 34 94 0 48E2. Business Development and Practices 0 10 22 81 0
this objective is to incorporate humanities issues into existingcourses in the civil engineering curriculum. It has been suggested that much of the exposure ofcivil engineering students to the humanities must come from civil engineering professors12.Hayes12 highlighted the importance of having civil engineering professors broadly read in thehumanities incorporate ethics, knowledge of engineering history, and broader societal concernsinto the classroom at every opportunity as a means to provide civil engineering students exposureto the humanities12. In general, the civil engineering professors will be best at framingengineering problems and solutions for students from the humanist viewpoint and discussing theimpacts from a humanist perspective
compared to my colleagues, my immediate supervisor generally believes that I have good communication skills.”PM 2-2. 50% or more of CE graduates will respond “agree or strongly agree” to the statement, “My engineering education at UE prepared me for the ethical situations I have encountered in my career as an engineer”PM 2-3. 50% or more of CE graduates will respond “agree or strongly agree” to the statement “I stay abreast of current issues in civil engineering by reading professional publications on a monthly basis.”PM 2-4. 50% or more of CE graduates will respond that they have active memberships in ASCE.PM 2-5. 50% or more of CE graduates will answer in the affirmative to the statement “I have
ofspecific courses to meet these requirements. Examples of these new suggested courses included: required senior level course in professional and legal issues professional practice course general engineering economics and ethics courses engineering history and heritage course ethics course and an engineering practice course discussion of public policy in some of the CE courses. Page 25.1217.13 40 35 Number of respondents 30 25 68% 20
correlating with the students’ finalgrades, the discussion board learning analytics help instructors pinpoint students falling behindin their participation. Learning analytics collect an immense amount of data on student interactions. Despite theopportunity to make data-informed course development decisions, the required parsing toorganize and analyze the learning analytics is a time-intensive process. Therefore, education isneeded on the organization and analysis processes to inform instructors and eventually encourageuse of LMS learning analytics. Additionally, the availability of every students’ interaction dataon every course in an LMS establishes ethical and privacy concerns for students [31]. In highereducation, FERPA protects the
. evaluations. Be aware of, be Teamwork and leadership: Acknowledge the importance - Need to abide with willing to receive, of teamwork, leadership, diversity, and inclusion. code of conduct, and be attentive to Professional attitudes: Acknowledge professional explicitly and a particular attitudes relevant to the practice of civil engineering, detailed in the phenomenon or including creativity, curiosity, flexibility, and syllabi and revisited behavior dependability. throughout semester. Ethical responsibilities: Acknowledge the importance of ethical behavior
conducting research in watershed sciences. – 3.14 • I have a good understanding of the role of ethics in scientific investigations. – 3.00 • I am confident that I understand how to conduct scientific research. – 2.86 • I know everything that I need to know to conduct scientific research in the library. – 2.71 • I understand the processes used to monitor water quality. – 2.57 • I plan on going to work after graduate school. – 2.43 • I can visually examine a quantity of water and tell whether it’s safe for drinking Page 13.701.8 or not. – 1.86 • There are winners and losers in environmental conflicts; it’s as simple as
, transportation, shelter, and effective waste management while conserving and protecting environmental quality and the natural resource base essential for future development.”As Mays2 points out, the concept of sustainability is not new. However, officially recognition ofthe concept in practice has come relatively recently. For example, The ASCE Board of Directors Page 13.915.2introduced the concept into their Code of Ethics a little more than a decade ago3.Equipping civil engineers at the university level to plan and design sustainable developments,buildings, and processes is also relatively new. Steineman4 reviewed the history of
Administration 7 Experiments 19 Globalization Problem Recognition and 8 20 Leadership Solving 9 Design 21 Teamwork 10 Sustainability 22 Attitudes Contemporary Issues and 11 23 Lifelong Learning Historical Perspectives Professional and Ethical 12 Risk and Uncertainty 24 Responsibility
) Design and conduct experiments, as well as to analyze and interpret data (c) Design a system, component, or process to meet desired needs within realistic constraints such as economic, environmental, social, political, ethical, health and safety, manufacturability, and sustainability (d) Function on multi-disciplinary teams (e) Identify, formulate, and solve engineering problems (f) Understand professional and ethical responsibility (g) Communicate effectively (h) Understand the impact of engineering solutions in a global, economic, environmental, and societal context (i) Recognize the need for and engage in life-long learning (j) Have a knowledge of
activities. Mentors have commented on how much material theythemselves take for granted that is critical to teach to the students. The students appreciate havingprofessional contact, although some have expressed feeling intimidated by doing schoolwork for apossible future employer. Fulltime faculty have appreciated the mentoring interaction andreinforcement of the need for a strong work ethic and communication skills.A new special topics course, “Advanced Land Development Design” is being taught in Spring 2007by volunteer practicing engineers from three LDDI firms (See Appendix D for a course descriptionand objectives). The philosophy of the course is to build complexity from the 4274 course bydigging deeper into three particularly important areas
quality and rigor; and appropriate experience based uponbroad technical and professional practice guidelines which provide sufficient flexibilityfor a wide range of roles in engineering practice.Table 2. ABET outcome criteria for engineering baccalaureate graduates. 3a: An ability to apply knowledge of mathematics, science, and engineering 3b: An ability to design and conduct experiments as well as to analyze and interpret data 3c: An ability to design a system, component, or process to meet desired needs within Hard skills realistic constraints such as economic, environmental, social, political, ethical, heath and safety, manufacturability, and sustainability. 3e: An
defined equivalent of a master’s degree in engineering as30 credits beyond the BS degree of “acceptable” upper level undergraduate or graduate levelcoursework in “technical or professional practice” topic areas from “approved providers”.“Acceptable” coursework is defined as being equivalent in intellectual rigor and learningassessment to engineering coursework provided by ABET EAC accredited programs.“Technical or professional practice” topic areas are defined as engineering, math and science inthe technical realm, and professional practice topics such as business, communications, contractlaw, management, ethics, public policy, and quality control. Coursework could be allengineering, or could be part engineering and the rest math, science and
design background. The Civil Engineering Body of Knowledge for the 21st Century1 and The Engineer of 2020:Visions of Engineering in the New Century2 document a call for broadly trained civil engineersconversant not only with mathematics, science and design, but also multi-disciplinary teams,professional ethics, communications, globalization, life-long learning, contemporary issues, pro-ject management, construction, asset management, business and public policy and administrationfundamentals, and leadership principles. Further, there is a push by the CEE profession overall topromote change in university undergraduate curricula by revising the basic civil engineering ac-creditation criteria to embrace as much of the breadth as possible. This
States. He is a licensed professional engineer in multiple states. Dr. Barry’s areas of research include assessment of professional ethics, teaching and learning in engineering education, nonverbal communication in the classroom, and learning through historical engineering accomplishments. He has authored and co-authored a significant number of journal articles and book chapters on these topics.Dr. Beth Lin Hartmann P.E., Iowa State University Beth Lin Hartmann is a senior lecturer in construction engineering at Iowa State University. Hartmann served 20 years in the U.S. Navy Civil Engineer Corps before joining the faculty at Iowa State in 2009. She currently teaches the civil and construction engineering design-build
audiences 4. an ability to recognize ethical and professional responsibilities in engineering situations and make informed judgments, which must consider the impact of engineering solutions in global, economic, environmental, and societal contexts 5. an ability to function effectively on a team whose members together provide leadership, create a collaborative and inclusive environment, establish goals, plan tasks, and meet objectives 6. an ability to develop and conduct appropriate experimentation, analyze and interpret data, and use engineering judgment to draw conclusions 7. an ability to acquire and apply new knowledge as needed, using appropriate learning
responses to the effectiveness of writing exercises inaccomplishing ABET outcomes f through k.Slightly higher ratings were received for WWE for outcomes f, h and i. Similarly, outcomes g, jand k received slightly higher ratings for EES. Again, these observations are as anticipated giventhe nature of the writing exercises incorporated in each of the courses. Writing intensiveexercises in EES enhanced the communication skills, knowledge of contemporary issues andtechniques and skills required for engineering practice11. The design intensive exercises in WWEhelped students realize the professional and ethical responsibility, awareness of broad educationfor engineering solutions, and the need for life-long learning to stay up to the trends
an HSI”, Proceedings of the 2020ASEE Annual Conference and Exposition, Montreal, Canada, June 21-24, 2020.[8] American Society of Civil Engineers, “Code of Ethics,” ASCE, https://www.asce.org/code-of-ethics/ [Accessed February 4, 2020].
engineering.” 2002. William Oakes, et al. 32nd ASEE/IEEE Frontiers in EducationConference; “ASEE and service learning”. 2000. Edmund Tsang. Prism.5 “Engineering education and service-learning.” 2004. Rachel L. Vaughn and Sarena D. Seifer. Community-CampusPartnerships for Health, June.6 “Service-learning and engineering ethics.” 1999. Michael S. Pritchard. International Conference on Ethics inEngineering and Computer Science, March.7 The Chronicle of Higher Education, 8/15/20058 “Integration of Service Learning into Civil and Environmental Engineering Curriculum.” 2005. Thomsa Piechotaand Shashi Nambisan. Proceedings of the Annual Conference of the American Society for Engineering Education,Portland, OR.9 “Work in Progress
Page 23.457.8 practice for professional engineering; 4. Design or develop solutions to complex engineering problems in accordance with good practice for professional engineering; 5. Be responsible for making decisions on part or all of one or more complex engineering activities; 6. Manage part or all of one or more complex engineering activities in accordance with good engineering management practice; 7. Identify, assess and manage engineering risk; 8. Conduct engineering activities to an ethical standard at least equivalent to the relevant code of ethical conduct; 9. Recognise the reasonably foreseeable social, cultural and environmental effects of professional engineering activities generally
to the EAC/ABET general engineering program Criteria 3 (d),and (f) through (j): Page 15.125.2 (d) an ability to function on multidisciplinary teams, (f) an understanding of professional, and ethical responsibility, (g) an ability to communicate effectively, (h) …to understand the impact of engineering solutions in a global, economic, environmental, and societal context. (i) a recognition of the need for, and an ability to engage in life-long learning, and (j) a knowledge of contemporary issues.1,2Incorporating these outcomes into Civil Engineering curricula has been challenging since mostCivil
y 2graduates who have an ability to function on in diverse teams multidisciplinarymultidisciplinary and diverse teams (ABET D). and/or diverse teams. Outcome 1: StudentsGoal 3 - Objective 2: The Civil Engineering will take pride in theProgram at Rowan University will produce profession of civilgraduates who have an understanding of engineering and nprofessional and ethical responsibilities (ABET recognize theirF). professional and