Impacts of Social and Equity-Centered Instruction on Students’ Ability to Navigate Related Tradeoffs in Systems-Level Design

Brenda Read-Daily; Kurt M. Degoede; Rachel Koh

Download Paper | Permalink

Conference: 2024 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition
Location: Portland, Oregon
Publication Date: June 23, 2024
Start Date: June 23, 2024
End Date: July 12, 2024
Conference Session: Design in Engineering Education Division (DEED) - DEI and Design Education
Tagged Division: Design in Engineering Education Division (DEED)
Tagged Topic: Diversity
Permanent URL: https://peer.asee.org/47570

Request a correction

Paper Authors

biography

Brenda Read-Daily Elizabethtown College orcid.org/0000-0002-8137-7912

visit author page

Dr. Brenda Read-Daily is an Associate Professor of Engineering at Elizabethtown College in Pennsylvania. She holds a BS in Civil Engineering from Bradley University, and a MS and PhD in Environmental Engineering from the University of Notre Dame.

visit author page

biography

Kurt M. Degoede Elizabethtown College orcid.org/0000-0002-0118-4951

visit author page

Professor of Engineering and Physics, Elizabethtown College. His research interests in biomechanics include developing clinical instruments for rehabilitation and human performance. Dr. DeGoede teaches upper-level undergraduate mechanical engineering using mastery-based assessment models and project-based learning, design courses, and first-year multidisciplinary courses.

visit author page

author page

Rachel Koh Smith College

Download Paper | Permalink

Abstract

Engineers effective at creating value for society must frame that work through a lens of equity and social justice. They must identify who is affected positively and negatively by their solutions across all stages of development, manufacture, distribution, use, and disposal. In this work-in-progress paper, we examine the first stage of a four-year curriculum initiative to develop these skills in engineering students. Our four-year sequence of open-ended project courses forms the backbone of this project. Students are introduced to several tools of human-centered design in the first-year introduction to engineering sequence. They work with a local partner in a community-based learning project in the second year and complete a three-semester entrepreneurially-minded capstone experience in the last three semesters. Additionally, we have implemented several specific assignments in a Sustainable Energy Systems Design course where students must specifically address equity concerns in four project assignments.

This paper will examine the effectiveness of these assignments in eliciting the students to navigate complex questions of equity and the related tradeoffs. We assess the capacity of the students to identify design alternatives to mitigate the negative effects on marginalized populations. The paper will provide re-designed activities based on this analysis along with preliminary data on the use of a pre and post-assessment of the student's ability to transfer these skills to new projects. Students across all four years of project-based learning will be asked to • consider a contemporary design challenge, • identify people affected by this design from concept to repurpose/recycle/landfill, • and discuss how these factors should affect the design of the solution. The students will be given the same design challenge at the beginning and end of the semester, and we will examine the effect of academic progress and the specific Sustainable Energy Systems Design course assignments on the student's ability to identify and articulate appropriate concerns and solutions. The data set also includes students studying the same course as part of a one-semester project-based curriculum at a partner location.

Citation
Format

Read-Daily, B., & Degoede, K. M., & Koh, R. (2024, June), Impacts of Social and Equity-Centered Instruction on Students’ Ability to Navigate Related Tradeoffs in Systems-Level Design Paper presented at 2024 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition, Portland, Oregon. https://peer.asee.org/47570

TY - CPAPER
AB - Engineers effective at creating value for society must frame that work through a lens of equity and social justice. They must identify who is affected positively and negatively by their solutions across all stages of development, manufacture, distribution, use, and disposal. In this work-in-progress paper, we examine the first stage of a four-year curriculum initiative to develop these skills in engineering students. Our four-year sequence of open-ended project courses forms the backbone of this project. Students are introduced to several tools of human-centered design in the first-year introduction to engineering sequence. They work with a local partner in a community-based learning project in the second year and complete a three-semester entrepreneurially-minded capstone experience in the last three semesters. Additionally, we have implemented several specific assignments in a Sustainable Energy Systems Design course where students must specifically address equity concerns in four project assignments.

This paper will examine the effectiveness of these assignments in eliciting the students to navigate complex questions of equity and the related tradeoffs. We assess the capacity of the students to identify design alternatives to mitigate the negative effects on marginalized populations. The paper will provide re-designed activities based on this analysis along with preliminary data on the use of a pre and post-assessment of the student&#39;s ability to transfer these skills to new projects. Students across all four years of project-based learning will be asked to
• consider a contemporary design challenge,
• identify people affected by this design from concept to repurpose/recycle/landfill,
• and discuss how these factors should affect the design of the solution.
The students will be given the same design challenge at the beginning and end of the semester, and we will examine the effect of academic progress and the specific Sustainable Energy Systems Design course assignments on the student&#39;s ability to identify and articulate appropriate concerns and solutions. The data set also includes students studying the same course as part of a one-semester project-based curriculum at a partner location.

AU - Brenda Read-Daily
AU - Kurt M. Degoede
AU - Rachel Koh
CY - Portland, Oregon
DA - 2024/06/23
PB - ASEE Conferences
TI - Impacts of Social and Equity-Centered Instruction on Students’ Ability to Navigate Related Tradeoffs in Systems-Level Design
UR - https://peer.asee.org/47570
ER -