Effectiveness of Scrum in Enhancing Feedback Accessibility among Undergraduate Research Students: Insights from Integrated Feedback Dynamics Framework

Sakhi Aggrawal; Alejandra J. Magana

Download Paper | Permalink

Conference: 2024 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition
Location: Portland, Oregon
Publication Date: June 23, 2024
Start Date: June 23, 2024
End Date: July 12, 2024
Conference Session: Educational Research and Methods Division (ERM) Technical Session 17
Tagged Division: Educational Research and Methods Division (ERM)
Permanent URL: https://peer.asee.org/47224

Request a correction

Paper Authors

biography

Sakhi Aggrawal Purdue University orcid.org/0000-0002-2274-0152

visit author page

Sakhi Aggrawal is a Graduate Research Fellow in Computer and Information Technology department at Purdue University. She completed her master’s degree in Business Analytics from Imperial College London and bachelor’s degree in Computer and Information Technology and Organizational Leadership from Purdue University. She worked in industry for several years with her latest jobs being as project manager at Google and Microsoft. Her current research focuses on integrating project management processes in undergraduate education. Her main goal is to understand how work management and product development practices widely used in industry can be modified and adapted to streamline undergraduate STEM education.

visit author page

biography

Alejandra J. Magana Purdue University orcid.org/0000-0001-6117-7502

visit author page

Alejandra J. Magana, Ph.D., is the W.C. Furnas Professor in Enterprise Excellence in the Department of Computer and Information Technology and Professor of Engineering Education at Purdue University.

visit author page

Download Paper | Permalink

Abstract

Background: Undergraduate research experiences hold great potential for students to develop critical thinking skills, engage in hands-on learning, and contribute to academic and professional growth. Central to the success of these research experiences is the accessibility of timely and constructive feedback, which aids in students' development and performance. Traditional approaches to research program management in such contexts often lack structured feedback mechanisms. However, the Scrum framework of project management offers a structured framework that could potentially enhance feedback accessibility.

Purpose: This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of the Scrum framework in enhancing feedback accessibility and effectiveness in undergraduate research mentoring. The specific research question of the study is: "How does the implementation of the Scrum framework influence the dimensions of feedback sources, timing, content, and use in undergraduate research programs?" By focusing on this overarching question, the study seeks to offer valuable insights into the potential benefits and challenges of applying agile methodologies, aiming to enrich the mentoring experience and improve learning outcomes and student satisfaction.

Methods: The study was conducted in a senior-level undergraduate course offered at a large midwestern university. The course focused on project management, research skills, and mentorship in the context of a research project. Data were collected through guided student reflections at the end of the semester and analyzed thematically according to the " Integrated Feedback Dynamics Framework (IFDF)", comprising four dimensions: Feedback Sources, Feedback Timing, Feedback Content, and Feedback Use.

Results: Implementation of Scrum resulted in a diverse range of feedback sources, with students valuing the multiple perspectives received. Timely feedback emerged as a significant benefit, with weekly stand-up meetings and milestone retrospectives allowing for rapid, responsive feedback. The content of feedback was praised for its specificity and relevance, guiding students in refining their research effectively. Furthermore, students demonstrated a strong engagement with the feedback, applying it methodically to their work and expressing appreciation for the iterative improvement it enabled.

Implications: The findings highlight the transformative power of structured feedback in Scrum, enhancing teamwork, co-regulation, and metacognition in undergraduate research. The study suggests the potential of agile methodologies like Scrum in educational settings to improve feedback processes and student engagement. However, it acknowledges the need for a balance between structured feedback and self-directed learning in research education.

Citation
Format

Aggrawal, S., & Magana, A. J. (2024, June), Effectiveness of Scrum in Enhancing Feedback Accessibility among Undergraduate Research Students: Insights from Integrated Feedback Dynamics Framework Paper presented at 2024 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition, Portland, Oregon. https://peer.asee.org/47224

TY - CPAPER
AB - Background: Undergraduate research experiences hold great potential for students to develop critical thinking skills, engage in hands-on learning, and contribute to academic and professional growth. Central to the success of these research experiences is the accessibility of timely and constructive feedback, which aids in students&#39; development and performance. Traditional approaches to research program management in such contexts often lack structured feedback mechanisms. However, the Scrum framework of project management offers a structured framework that could potentially enhance feedback accessibility.

Purpose: This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of the Scrum framework in enhancing feedback accessibility and effectiveness in undergraduate research mentoring. The specific research question of the study is: &quot;How does the implementation of the Scrum framework influence the dimensions of feedback sources, timing, content, and use in undergraduate research programs?&quot; By focusing on this overarching question, the study seeks to offer valuable insights into the potential benefits and challenges of applying agile methodologies, aiming to enrich the mentoring experience and improve learning outcomes and student satisfaction.

Methods: The study was conducted in a senior-level undergraduate course offered at a large midwestern university. The course focused on project management, research skills, and mentorship in the context of a research project. Data were collected through guided student reflections at the end of the semester and analyzed thematically according to the &quot; Integrated Feedback Dynamics Framework (IFDF)&quot;, comprising four dimensions: Feedback Sources, Feedback Timing, Feedback Content, and Feedback Use.

Results: Implementation of Scrum resulted in a diverse range of feedback sources, with students valuing the multiple perspectives received. Timely feedback emerged as a significant benefit, with weekly stand-up meetings and milestone retrospectives allowing for rapid, responsive feedback. The content of feedback was praised for its specificity and relevance, guiding students in refining their research effectively. Furthermore, students demonstrated a strong engagement with the feedback, applying it methodically to their work and expressing appreciation for the iterative improvement it enabled.

Implications: The findings highlight the transformative power of structured feedback in Scrum, enhancing teamwork, co-regulation, and metacognition in undergraduate research. The study suggests the potential of agile methodologies like Scrum in educational settings to improve feedback processes and student engagement. However, it acknowledges the need for a balance between structured feedback and self-directed learning in research education.
AU - Sakhi Aggrawal
AU - Alejandra J. Magana
CY - Portland, Oregon
DA - 2024/06/23
PB - ASEE Conferences
TI - Effectiveness of Scrum in Enhancing Feedback Accessibility among Undergraduate Research Students: Insights from Integrated Feedback Dynamics Framework
UR - https://peer.asee.org/47224
ER -