Asee peer logo
Well-matched quotation marks can be used to demarcate phrases, and the + and - operators can be used to require or exclude words respectively
Displaying results 5791 - 5820 of 8077 in total
Conference Session
Outreach Projects and General Energy Education
Collection
2007 Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Robert Fletcher, Lawrence Technological University
Tagged Divisions
Energy Conversion and Conservation
. The planninggroup reviewed the RFP and provided guidance regarding content and approach for the LTUproposal. From the first meeting we focused on two areas, writing a winning proposal and howwe could involve students at every level of the project. Mr. Pratt provided initial input as to thebest on-campus location site for the project, and how best to design the system to comply withthe grant requirements. Because the grant was for a maxim of $60,000, we knew additionalfunding was going to be required. Our Dean of Engineering has been very supportive of ourAlternative Energy program and assured us that if we got the grant that he would help us securethe additional funds to complete the project. This was vital, as the proposal required us
Conference Session
Assessing Entrepreneurship Programs
Collection
2007 Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Jeffrey Blessing, Milwaukee School of Engineering; John D. Gassert, Milwaukee School of Engineering; Lawrence J. Schmedeman, Milwaukee School of Engineering; Larry Fennigkoh, Milwaukee School of Engineering
Tagged Divisions
Entrepreneurship & Engineering Innovation
entrepreneurshipeducation. In contrast, we are just getting started on our endeavor to introduce entrepreneurshipeducation and to ultimately make it a permanent part of our curriculum. Page 12.917.3In summary, here are the main challenges to our efforts: CHALLENGES TO INSTILLING ENTREPRENEURSHIP EDUCATION AT MSOE 1. How to achieve our main goal of getting the schools of business and engineering to work together as peers in an effort to promote entrepreneurship. 2. How to encourage faculty to take on the new task of teaching entrepreneurship when they are already handling a heavy workload. 3. How to get students excited about
Conference Session
FPD9 - First Year Learning & Assessment
Collection
2008 Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Eric Johnson, Valparaiso University; Doug Tougaw, Valparaiso University; Kenneth Leitch, Valparaiso University; Barbara Engerer, Valparaiso University
Tagged Divisions
First-Year Programs
andICE are turned in the next day at the start of the laboratory period. Students have access toinstructors and peer tutoring prior to submittal of the homework assignment so that they mayseek additional assistance with the new concepts if needed.The laboratory assignment further reinforces the module concepts by hands-on experience. Forthe fluid mechanics module, students learn to how to estimate the flow rate (volume per time) ofwater out of a hole. Three methods are utilized: 1) Bernoulli’s equation and flow rate, 2) volumeof water and elapsed time, and 3) particle dynamics and flow rate. Figures 3 and 4 depict aschematic of the test apparatus and a photograph of the test, respectively. Students are requiredto write a comprehensive laboratory
Conference Session
Multidisciplinary Course Innovation II
Collection
2008 Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
James Farison, Baylor University
Tagged Divisions
Multidisciplinary Engineering
components - Homework and classroom tests (50%) Homework assignments 10% Midterm test 15% Final exam (comprehensive) 25% Page 13.747.5 Special grading components - Individual student project reports and presentations (50%) 1. Applied/practical - imaging systems and hardware 15% 2. Peer-reviewed image processing research material 15% 3. Student-formulated image processing “research” project
Conference Session
FPD9 - First Year Learning & Assessment
Collection
2008 Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Joe Guarino, Boise State University; Janet Callahan, Boise State University; Seung Youn Chyung, Boise State University; Randi Walters, Boise State University; Bill Clement, Boise State University
Tagged Divisions
First-Year Programs
is a Junior majoring in Geosciences at Boise State University. Ms. Walters is also a tutor and peer instructor for the Engineering with Precalculus class offered by the College of Engineering at Boise State University.Bill Clement, Boise State University Dr. Clement is an Associate Research Professor in the Center for the Geophysical Investigation of the Shallow Subsurface (CGISS), at Boise State University. Page 13.393.1© American Society for Engineering Education, 2008 Developing and Assessing Engineering-Based Modules for a Freshman Engineering ClassAbstractMost
Conference Session
Mechanics and the Internet
Collection
2008 Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Shahnam Navaee, Georgia Southern University
Tagged Divisions
Mechanics
Academic Development through Prescribed Undergraduate ProjectsAbstractIn this paper a methodology for enhancing the academic development of sophomore-levelengineering and engineering technology students using undergraduate projects is outlined anddiscussed. The specific sample project presented in the paper involves the development ofMATLAB script files and LabVIEW Virtual Instruments (VIs) for solving several EngineeringMechanics problems. The development of the solution for these problems involves theutilization of a number of valuable programming tools and powerful techniques. The selectedstudents will be guided to write a proposal to seek funding for the project through the CollegeOffice of Undergraduate Research (COUR
Collection
2008 GSW
Authors
Mohan A. Ketkar; Nripendra N. Sarker
other (through peer evaluation of team members on these characteristics)Performance Criteria ‘f’ Proceedings of the 2008 ASEE Gulf-Southwest Conference The University of New Mexico - Albuquerque Copyright © 2008, American Society for Engineering EducationTAC Criterion 2, Outcome ‘f’, “an ability to identify, analyze and solve technical problems. 1. Ability to identify engineering/technical/computing problems: Given a problem, the student is able to (i) understand the given problem and identify the subject area and concept involved, (ii) convert the problem into a well labeled sketch (such as free body diagram, flow chart, functional
Conference Session
New Trends in ECE Education II
Collection
2008 Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Aleksandr Panchul, UTSA; David Akopian, UTSA
Tagged Divisions
Electrical and Computer
% send email on their phones, exchanging some 200 email messages eachweek. 66% email peers about classes; 44% email for studying. In contrast, only 43% email onPCs, exchanging an average of only 2 messages per week. Only 20% had used a PDA. 71% ofthe subjects preferred receiving educational materials on mobile phones rather than PCs. 93%felt that its valuable to use phones for teaching. In the UK it is estimated that 81% of 11-15 yearolds and 96% of 16-24 year olds have a mobile phone [7]. Similar projects have been establishedin Europe as well. An example of a pan-European research and development study with partnersin Italy, Sweden and the UK is the "m-learning" project [8]. Its aim is to use portabletechnologies to provide literacy and
Conference Session
High-School Engineering Education
Collection
2009 Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Muhammad Kehnemouyi, Montgomery College; Uchechukwu Abanulo, Montgomery College
Tagged Divisions
K-12 & Pre-College Engineering
student and his/her major), enhancement of the student’s college admissionsprofile, and motivation for early career decision making by student.In order to be accepted into the College Institute, students must: Page 14.561.2 ≠ be enrolled as seniors at participating schools ≠ have completed all high school graduation requirements ≠ have a cumulative GPA of 3.5 or above ≠ must have SAT Reading, Writing and Math scores of 550 or above (or have met the eligibility score requirement in Montgomery College’s placement test)To continue the program, students are required to successfully
Conference Session
Innovations in ECE Education II
Collection
2009 Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Jan Machotka, University of South Australia; Zorica Nedic, University of South Australia; Andrew Nafalski, University of South Australia; Ozdemir Gol, University of South Australia
Tagged Divisions
Electrical and Computer
reports ≠ Assessment ≠ Evaluation and reflectionCollaboration among students can be encouraged during preparation, conduct and analysis ofexperiments, where students are asked to work in teams. This can be implemented for peer assessment, Page 14.98.4evaluation and reflection as well. Findings from our survey provide some information about studentcollaboration before, during and after the practical experiment.Remote laboratoryA remote laboratory (RL) allows a real physical system set in a laboratory to be remotely controlled from acomputer via the Internet using virtual instruments. The system also enables experimental data to becollected and
Conference Session
Critical Thinking and Creative Arts
Collection
2009 Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Christy Moore, University of Texas, Austin; D'Arcy Randall, University of Texas, Austin; Hillary Hart, University of Texas, Austin
Tagged Divisions
Liberal Education
mother’s gravesurrounded by his “true peers,” he weeps (see Fig. 3). Many students were moved by this sceneof a “grown man crying.” For one student, the scene “brought the documentary into [the realmof] more personal feelings instead of just being a movie”. Another wrote that the scene “wentagainst the filmmaker’s point by showing [that Bradley] was not some emotionless monster, andthat he is a human with cares and worries.” Page 14.1180.6 Figure 3. Gary Bradley reflects on the impact of his bankruptcy.Students were also stirred by scenes featuring Curtis Peterson (shown in Fig. 4.) whoselivelihood as a farmer is threatened by
Conference Session
Software and Hardware for Educators II
Collection
2009 Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Joseph Tront, Virginia Tech; Kimberly Filer, Virginia Tech; Glenda Scales, Virginia Tech; Jane Prey, Microsoft Research
Tagged Divisions
Computers in Education
used to input standard mouse-typecommands as well as gesture commands and electronic ink drawings. These combined featureshold the promise of facilitating dynamic and broadly informed faculty presentations while at thesame time allowing students to be more natural in their learning tasks such as note-taking andpeer to peer collaboration.Several software packages are available to support the pedagogical needs of the engineeringclassroom as well as typical engineering group collaborative environments. These packages alsoallow for a highly interactive environment with both teacher-student and student-student bi-directional real-time interactions. This paper describes some faculty experiences using tablet-focused tools such as Classroom Presenter
Conference Session
New Learning Paradigms II
Collection
2009 Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Laura Hahn, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign; Alan Hansen, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign
Tagged Divisions
Educational Research and Methods
professional and personaldevelopment. A number of prompts were used to guide students to reflect on various aspects oftheir experience, including communication and teamwork, critical cultural incidents, andprogress on their engineering projects.A third component of the learning outcomes assessment of this experience involved the South Page 14.840.5African students. At the end of the program they were asked to write a short paper reflecting onwhat they had learned. Prompts were developed in collaboration with the ILLINOIS and UKZNsupervising professors and the educational specialist. Table 1 summarizes the assessments.Assessment Methods and Purposes
Conference Session
FPD3 -- Professional Issues for First-Year Courses
Collection
2006 Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Sven Bilen, Pennsylvania State University; Beverly Jaeger, Northeastern University
Tagged Divisions
First-Year Programs
of engineeringthat they themselves find interesting. The instructions provided to them were as follows: GEU 110 Engineering Design One-Minute Engineer Fall 2005 Due: on selected date Professor Jaeger Overview: Each student will prepare a “One-Minute Engineer” (OME) piece for presentation to the class. You may work in pairs or individually on this. These presentations should be coordinated with Professor Jaeger before your proposed presentation day. The only write up required is an e- mail at least 24 hours prior to the class for feedback and
Conference Session
Technology for Faculty Development and Classroom Management
Collection
2017 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Rustin Deane Webster, Purdue University, New Albany
Tagged Divisions
New Engineering Educators
visiting assistant professor at a research one land grant university heforecasted that he would be introduced to many of the same hurdles as proposed byBrent and Felder (1998): Writing proposals and trying to get them funded, attracting and learning how to deal with graduate students, and having to churn out a large number of refereed 2 papers while you were still trying to figure out how to do research. You may remember the incredibly time consuming labor of planning and teaching new courses and the headaches of dealing with bored classes and poor student performance and possibly cheating and poor ratings and a host of other problems you never thought about when
Conference Session
Emerging Computing and Information Technologies I
Collection
2017 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Damla Turgut, University of Central Florida; Lisa Massi, University of Central Florida; Salih Safa Bacanli, University of Central Florida; Neda Hajiakhoond Bidoki, University of Central Florida
Tagged Topics
Diversity
Tagged Divisions
Computing & Information Technology
level of interest incontinuing on to graduate/professional school (Lopatto, 2004, 2007; Massi et al., 2011), andare more likely to enroll in graduate/professional school compared to non-participants(Hathaway, Nagda, & Gregerman, 2002). REU participants from underrepresented groups aremore likely to be attracted to academic careers in the computing professoriate if they gainexperience collaborating with their peers and mentors, learn about social impacts related tocareers in computing research, understand the graduate admissions process, and familiarizethemselves with graduate student life (Tamer & Stout, 2016).High quality faculty-student mentor interactions are characterized by faculty preparation forthe arrival of the student
Conference Session
Women in Engineering Division Technical Session 5
Collection
2017 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Anne-Marie A Lerner, University of Wisconsin, Platteville; Christopher Frayer, University of Wisconsin - Platteville
Tagged Topics
Diversity
Tagged Divisions
Women in Engineering
university. In total, the annual budgetis approximately $6,500, for a program that affects upward of 20 faculty and academic staff annually. 3Faculty participants see more benefits; for example, there are (independent of the NFLC) modest start-up packages that new faculty access through an internal grant process. The start-up packages are opento all new faculty, but those who attend the NFLC programming are able to share and refine their ideasin the space afforded by the community. In short, it behooves a new faculty member to attend thesemeetings so they can write a stronger proposal.Faculty are also introduced to best practices for retaining URMs and scholarship in that area throughcollaboration
Conference Session
Minorities in Engineering Division Technical Session 7
Collection
2017 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Jinny Rhee, San Jose State University; Camille Johnson, San Jose State University; Clifton M. Oyamot Jr., San Jose State University
Tagged Topics
Diversity
Tagged Divisions
Minorities in Engineering
that thesense of belonging in women students is consistently higher in departments where they arerepresented in higher numbers9. At Arizona State University, the long-term effects to a suite ofstrategies designed to increase sense of belonging were found to be an increase in retention from0.9% per year to 1.6% per year in their undergraduate engineering cohorts from 1998 to 201310.Four areas were identified at the University of Washington as being important to thedevelopment of community and belonging of ethnic minority students: co-curricular activities,peer support, faculty/department support, and residence programs. They found that supportmechanisms changed with time and responsive strategies should reflect that11. Sophomore andjunior level
Conference Session
Minorities in Engineering Division Technical Session 3
Collection
2017 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Tonya L. Peeples, University of Iowa; Tracy R. Peterson, The University of Iowa, College of Engineering; Mary K. Nyaema; Barbara Newhall, University of Iowa, Health and Human Physiology
Tagged Topics
Diversity
Tagged Divisions
Minorities in Engineering
. Activitiesof the program included: pre-test and post-test to gauge knowledge and interest; field trips todemonstrate green energy; professional STEM presenters; ArcGIS® software training todemonstrate geographical constraints. Field trips associated with the program included visits tothe Iowa Flood Center, to Iowa Hydraulics Modules and to the Kirkwood Community CollegeWind Turbine. The students worked in pairs and had to answer the question: Which geographicalfactors are most important when placing a wind turbine? Students presented the results of theirmapping exercise to their peers and mentors. Comparison of pre and post STEM interest surveyswere used to reveal the program impact, and provided guidance for further improvement of theprogram.17
Conference Session
Industrial Engineering Division Tech Session 1: IE-ing a Broader Perspective
Collection
2017 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Faisal Aqlan, Pennsylvania State University, Erie (Behrend College); Yuan-Han Huang, Pennsylvania State University, Erie (Behrend College); E. George Walters III P.E., Pennsylvania State University, Erie (Behrend College); Osama T. Al Meanazel, The Hashemite University
Tagged Divisions
Engineering Economy, Engineering Management, Industrial Engineering
past thirty years, many studies have emphasized the importance of applying ergonomicprinciples to product designs such as designing swimming suits3, non-powered hand tools4,writing instruments for children5, and luggage handles6. Thus, continuously injecting humanfactors and ergonomic (HFE) design concepts in the undergraduate engineering curriculum isimportant. It ensures that students have knowledge of applying HFE principles towards productdesign to minimize potential causes of injury and discomfort for the users7.Studies have noted that product design should address ergonomic considerations that take intoaccount the majority of customers’ capabilities and limitations when using the produce for itsintended purpose8. To discover the
Conference Session
Pre-college: Summer Experiences for Students and Teachers (1)
Collection
2017 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Kimberlyn Gray, West Virginia University Inst. of Tech.; Stephany Coffman-Wolph, West Virginia University Inst. of Tech.
Tagged Divisions
Pre-College Engineering Education Division
experiments orzip-lining with ecology experiments. Mentoring and peer networking opportunities for studentsinclude: (1) positive and encouraging interactions with faculty members who specialize invarious STEM fields, (2) informal interactions with college-age STEM students, and (3) buildingpeer relationships with other students with similar interests.Table 1. Example of a Weekday schedule for program 8:00 AM Breakfast 9:00 AM 10:00 AM Canoe Design Project 11:00 AM 12:00 Lunch PM 1:00 PM Class 1: Civil Engineering 2:00 PM 3:00 PM Class 2: Electrical Engineering 4:00 PM 5:00 PM Dinner 6:00 PM Guest Speaker: Physician 7:00 PM
Conference Session
First- and Second-year Design and Professional Development in BME
Collection
2017 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Emma K. Frow, Arizona State University; Barbara S. Smith, Arizona State University; Casey Jane Ankeny, Arizona State University
Tagged Topics
Diversity
Tagged Divisions
Biomedical
(Dym et al. 2005). At the start of the semester, students self-assemble into teams of 4-5,and each team chooses a lower-income country to explore. Over 14 weeks, teams use their chosencountry as a starting point to work through a cycle of biomedical device design, including broadscoping and needs assessment, problem definition, concept generation and iteration, CADprototyping, and design iteration based on peer, student instructor, and faculty feedback (see Table1). They also examine case studies of (successful and unsuccessful) biomedical device design,learn about healthcare innovation systems, and reflect on key challenges and best practices forbiomedical engineering design.Over 3 consecutive semesters, our students have developed a variety
Conference Session
Assessment Strategies in Mechanics
Collection
2020 ASEE Virtual Annual Conference Content Access
Authors
Geoffrey Recktenwald, Michigan State University; Tamara Bush, Michigan State University; Ron Averill, Michigan State University
Tagged Divisions
Mechanics
builds a framework for grading based on motivating students to develop thesepractices as their study habits.The method was developed and tested over a 3.5-year period in a Mechanics of Materials course.The results were very promising, with student improvements of at least one standard deviationwhen compared to their peers in traditional courses. The goal of this paper is to demonstrate thatthe method can be applied to more than just the original course. For this study the authors haveadopted and implemented the SMART method for a different course, Introduction to Dynamics.While the course is still part of the engineering mechanics curriculum, it has several importantfeatures that make it worthwhile to demonstrate the versatility of the SMART
Conference Session
Computers in Education Division Technical Session 10: STEM Outreach
Collection
2020 ASEE Virtual Annual Conference Content Access
Authors
Mahmoud K. Quweider, University of Texas Rio Grande Valley; Fitratullah Khan, University of Texas Rio Grande Valley; Liyu Zhang, University of Texas Rio Grande Valley; Yessica Rodriguez, University of Texas, Rio Grande Valley; Yessenia Rodriguez, University of Texas, Rio Grande Valley
Tagged Topics
Diversity
Tagged Divisions
Computers in Education
college awareness. endeavors. Applicants Skill- set Is dependable and Relates well to reliable/Has good peers/Commun attendance, icates openly punctuality, and with school record. staff Cooperates with school staff
Conference Session
Elementary Engineering
Collection
2018 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Brenda M. Capobianco, Purdue University, West Lafayette; James Lehman, Purdue University, West Lafayette
Tagged Divisions
Pre-College Engineering Education
3.00 4.00 2.00 2.00 2.75 goal, end user, client and client’s needs) 2 Express individual ideas in writing using models 2.00 3.00 3.00 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.00 3.00 2.00 2.75 or drawings. 3 Share individual ideas orally and express group 2.00 3.00 3.00 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.00 2.00 2.00 2.50 ideas in writing. 4 Collaborate with one or more peers throughout the design process for the selection of the most 3.00 3.00 3.00 2.00 2.75 4.00 3.00 3.00 3.00 3.25 promising solution. 5 Use of and access
Conference Session
IED Technical Session: Preparing for the Future Through Projects and Research
Collection
2018 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Gokhan Egilmez, University of New Haven; Dusan Sormaz, Ohio University; Ridvan Gedik, University of New Haven
Tagged Divisions
Industrial Engineering
; Systems Engineering, and Civil Engineering from Ohio University, and B.S. in Industrial Engineering from Istanbul Technical University, Turkey. His re- search interests cover a variety of topics that include engineering education, applied optimization and simulation modeling, social, economic and environmental life cycle assessment, data analytics, engineer- ing education, energy and sustainability, input-output analysis, transportation sustainability and safety. Gokhan has over 50 peer-reviewed publications in prestigious academic journals, books, and conference proceedings related to sustainable development, life cycle assessment, manufacturing system design and control, supply chain management, transportation safety
Conference Session
First-year Programs Division: Self Efficacy
Collection
2018 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Joshua L. Hertz, Northeastern University
Tagged Divisions
First-Year Programs
tosolve math problems, to be creative, to work collaboratively on a team, to understand science,and to perform a few other abilities. For every ability, the average student ranked themselvesabove average relative to peers. Data on incoming student self-efficacy towards general project-related tasks is shown infigure 1a, with results split by self-identified gender (a non-binary gender option was given, butsurveys that selected that response were too few to create a meaningful average). Differencesbetween genders were generally statistically insignificant except for the most general question of a) b) Figure 1. Responses to the (a) pre-class and (b) post-class survey questions on general engineering project self-efficacy, averaged
Conference Session
Design Assessment
Collection
2018 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Scott R. Bartholomew, Purdue Polytechnic Institute; Greg J. Strimel, Purdue Polytechnic Institute; Senay Purzer, Purdue University, West Lafayette (College of Engineering); Liwei Zhang, Purdue University, West Lafayette; Emily Yoshikawa, Purdue University, West Lafayette
Tagged Topics
Diversity
Tagged Divisions
Design in Engineering Education
level of academicachievement (Strimel et al., 2018). The purpose of these programs can often be viewed asproviding students with the information necessary to ensure the proper selection of anengineering discipline-specific major and the knowledge and skills necessary for success in theirselected major. The first-year engineering curriculum is often designed to reinforce basic scienceand mathematics concepts while developing a student’s engineering design capabilities.According to Strimel et al. (2018), the typical core requirements during a student’s first yearincludes physics, chemistry, multiple levels of calculus, and writing/composition as well as anengineering orientation seminar and multiple engineering courses focused on design
Conference Session
First-year Programs Division: Retention
Collection
2018 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Binod Tiwari, California State University, Fullerton; Pradeep Nair, California State University, Fullerton; Susamma Barua, California State University, Fullerton
Tagged Divisions
First-Year Programs
Engineering, to the first year engineering students with the aim to increase retention rate and reduce graduation time. Dr. Tiwari is an ABET program evaluator for ASEE.Dr. Pradeep Nair, California State University, Fullerton Pradeep Nair received his Ph. D. in Electrical Engineering from the University of Texas at San Antonio in 2009. His research interests include power/performance tradeoffs in the nanoscale domain, leakage power reduction in digital systems, computer performance analysis and evaluation, low Power FPGAs, and biomedical circuits and systems. He has published several peer-reviewed papers as part of his re- search. At CSUF, Dr. Nair has taught several engineering courses ranging from the freshman level to
Conference Session
Materials Division Technical Session 1
Collection
2018 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition
Authors
Megan Frary, Boise State University
Tagged Divisions
Materials
Understanding These Four Types of Mistakes Can Help Us Learn’ [21]. Write a short summary of each of the four kinds of mistakes. Which kind(s) do you make most often? Which kind do you think you are most likely to make it MSE 308?” ● As part of their weekly homework in week 9, students were asked, “Review the article ‘Why a Growth Mindset is Essential For Learning’ [22]. Which parts of the article resonate with you? Why? Has you approach to learning evolved in MSE 308 toward more of a growth mindset? Do you have ideas for things to try over the rest of the semester (or in future classes)?” ● As part of their weekly homework in week 13, students were asked, “Read the article ‘Forget Talent’ [23]. Which