Full Paper: Exploring the Relationship between Moral Intuitions and Ethics Education among First-Year Engineering Students in the US, Netherlands, and China

Aleia Frye; Scott Streiner

Download Paper | Permalink

Conference: FYEE 2025 Conference
Location: University of Maryland - College Park, Maryland
Publication Date: July 27, 2025
Start Date: July 27, 2025
End Date: July 29, 2025
Conference Session: Full Papers I
Tagged Topics: Diversity and FYEE 2025
Page Count: 10
DOI: 10.18260/1-2--55246
Permanent URL: https://peer.asee.org/55246
Download Count: 6

Scott Streiner is an Assistant Professor in the Industrial Engineering Department, teaches in the First-Year Engineering Program and works in the Engineering Education Research Center (EERC) in the Swanson School of Engineering at the University of Pittsburgh. Scott has received funding through NSF to conduct research on the impact of game-based learning on the development of first-year students’ ethical reasoning, as well as research on the development of culturally responsive ethics education in global contexts. He is an active member of the Kern Engineering Entrepreneurship Network (KEEN), the American Society for Engineering Education (ASEE), and the Institute of Industrial and Systems Engineers (IISE)

visit author page

Download Paper | Permalink

Abstract

In recent years, there has been an increase in public discourse on how to confront ethical dilemmas. Many widely publicized failures of engineering systems have been traced back to ethical lapses or decisions that did not account for potential societal impacts. This raises the question of how educational institutions, specifically engineering schools, should formally expose students to ethics education and how this education can help students make ethical decisions on an improved moral framework. Due to the global nature of the engineering profession, it is critical to incorporate the effect of national guidelines, cultures, and norms into the understanding of effective ethical decision making. Thus, this paper addresses the following research question: What is the nature of the differences between first-year engineering student moral intuitions across multiple countries? This research hypothesizes that there is a significant relationship between exposure to ethics education and moral intuitions and aims to challenge whether cultural and demographic differences mediate this relationship. This exploratory study utilized data from 1668 first-year engineering students residing in the US, Netherlands, and China from 2021 to 2024. Participants were asked to fill out the Moral Foundations Questionnaire (MFQ) to measure their priorities within moral decision-making. Participants were also asked if they had experienced various forms of exposure to ethics education. In addition, they were asked a variety of demographic questions, such as political affiliation, religious upbringing, gender, etc. This study utilizes descriptive statistical analysis to explore the relationship between first-year engineers’ students’ moral intuition, their previous exposures to ethics education, cultural differences, and other demographic variations. The analysis showed that students’ MFQ scores were higher when they had been previously formally exposed to ethics education, compared to students who had not. There was variation in MFQ scores depending on what type of formal exposure they had received. However, there was no meaningful difference between students’ overall MFQ averages based on country of origin, though there was some interesting variation among MFQ categories. In addition, there were significant differences in MFQ scores between students based on political affiliation and religious affiliation. These exploratory results reinforce the hypothesized relationship between moral intuitions and prior experience, culture, and background, potentially helping educators rethink the goals and nature of engineering ethics education.

Citation
Format

Frye, A., & Streiner, S. (2025, July), Full Paper: Exploring the Relationship between Moral Intuitions and Ethics Education among First-Year Engineering Students in the US, Netherlands, and China Paper presented at FYEE 2025 Conference, University of Maryland - College Park, Maryland. 10.18260/1-2--55246

TY - CPAPER
AB - In recent years, there has been an increase in public discourse on how to confront ethical dilemmas. Many widely publicized failures of engineering systems have been traced back to ethical lapses or decisions that did not account for potential societal impacts. This raises the question of how educational institutions, specifically engineering schools, should formally expose students to ethics education and how this education can help students make ethical decisions on an improved moral framework. Due to the global nature of the engineering profession, it is critical to incorporate the effect of national guidelines, cultures, and norms into the understanding of effective ethical decision making. Thus, this paper addresses the following research question: What is the nature of the differences between first-year engineering student moral intuitions across multiple countries?
This research hypothesizes that there is a significant relationship between exposure to ethics education and moral intuitions and aims to challenge whether cultural and demographic differences mediate this relationship. This exploratory study utilized data from 1668 first-year engineering students residing in the US, Netherlands, and China from 2021 to 2024. Participants were asked to fill out the Moral Foundations Questionnaire (MFQ) to measure their priorities within moral decision-making. Participants were also asked if they had experienced various forms of exposure to ethics education. In addition, they were asked a variety of demographic questions, such as political affiliation, religious upbringing, gender, etc. This study utilizes descriptive statistical analysis to explore the relationship between first-year engineers’ students’ moral intuition, their previous exposures to ethics education, cultural differences, and other demographic variations.
The analysis showed that students’ MFQ scores were higher when they had been previously formally exposed to ethics education, compared to students who had not. There was variation in MFQ scores depending on what type of formal exposure they had received. However, there was no meaningful difference between students’ overall MFQ averages based on country of origin, though there was some interesting variation among MFQ categories. In addition, there were significant differences in MFQ scores between students based on political affiliation and religious affiliation. These exploratory results reinforce the hypothesized relationship between moral intuitions and prior experience, culture, and background, potentially helping educators rethink the goals and nature of engineering ethics education.

AU - Aleia Frye
AU - Scott Streiner
CY - University of Maryland - College Park, Maryland
DA - 2025/07/27
PB - ASEE Conferences
TI - Full Paper: Exploring the Relationship between Moral Intuitions and Ethics Education among First-Year Engineering Students in the US, Netherlands, and China
UR - https://peer.asee.org/55246
DO - 10.18260/1-2--55246
ER -

Full Paper: Exploring the Relationship between Moral Intuitions and Ethics Education among First-Year Engineering Students in the US, Netherlands, and China

Paper Authors

Aleia Frye University of Pittsburgh

Scott Streiner University of Pittsburgh

Abstract

Citation

APA

APA - LaTeX bibitem

MLA

MLA - LaTeX bibitem

Bibtex

EndNote - RIS