: • An ability to function effectively on teams (Outcome e) • An ability to communicate effectively (Outcome g) • A recognition of the need for, and an ability to engage in lifelong learning (Outcome h) • An ability to understand professional, ethical and social responsibility (Outcome i) • A respect for diversity and a knowledge of contemporary professional, societal, and global issues (Outcome j)In the Mechanical Engineering Technology (MET) Program at Milwaukee School ofEngineering (MSOE), the Capstone Project course has been used a curricular point for bothinstruction and assessment with respect to these outcomes. The Capstone Project course is a 10
assessment,and maintainability (which, for geological engineering, often focuses on “design for lowmaintenance”). Design management skills include ethics exercises specific to geologicalengineering and project management exercises aimed at students who will enter the consultingengineering and construction industries.Design in Specialty Engineering Disciplines In any engineering discipline, a contrast may be made between “engineering science” and“engineering design” problems. Engineering science problems typically share the followingcharacteristics: • “the problem statement is compact and well-posed • the problem has readily identifiable closure • the solution is unique and compact • the problem uses
working in a global economy. In addition, it is important for engineers tounderstand that their work can have global implications and may impact the longterm viability oflife on the planet. Beyond humanitarian motivations, we ignore the developing world at our ownperil. Their development may have worldwide impacts such as global warming and globalcirculation of pesticides.According to the ABET criteria for accrediting engineering programs1, graduating students musthave:(h) [an understanding of] the impact of engineering solutions in a global, economic,environmental, and societal context(c) an ability to design a system... to meet desired needs within realistic constraints such aseconomic, environmental, social, political, ethical, health and
Spring 2004, Final Exam InvitationSpecific Instructor Evaluation of David DevineDid the service learning assignment enhance your learning of the subject matter?Yes NoHow/why not:Should a service learning assignment be a part of this class? Yes NoHow/why not:Did the ethics assignment enhance your learning of the subject matter?Yes NoHow/why not:Should an ethics assignment be a part of this class? Yes NoHow/why not:Is it necessary to have open book and open note exams for this class?Yes NoWhy/why not:Writing is important and should be included in assignments made in this class.Strongly Disagree Strongly Agree 1 2 3 4 5The questions that appear on the SPIE FORM are specific to the class. Questions are
. Page 11.880.3Assessment can become a motivator itself for supporting intentional learning, if the focus of theassessment is the entire learning process rather than knowledge outcomes alone. Liberativeassessment should fit into a larger picture related to the entire curriculum, in which courses arelinked to who students are as individual learners, and what motivates them to pursue engineering.In the first year, our institution’s introductory engineering design course engages studentidentities and introduces the ethics and social relevance of engineering. It is critical at this pointto hear students’ voices to learn what they bring into the program and how they think aboutengineering. Their questions can become a motivating force for the entire
outcomes weredivided into sub-outcomes that were more readily assessable.Assessment of the Program OutcomesOnce the outcomes were defined, we had to determine how to assess the student achievement ofthe outcomes. Of particular concern were the so-called “soft skills,” such as teamwork,communications skills, global perspectives, ethics, life-long learning, and contemporary issues.Assessment of these can be difficult at best, particularly when it comes to triangulating results;i.e., providing more than one method of assessing the outcomes. While some members of thefaculty desired to leave the soft skills to the students’ humanities and social science courses, thatwas not a practical solution for our program because there is a wide variety of
, and the Electrical Engineering department administers it2. “The program, which is open to all Penn State students, has many foci not usually found in undergraduate curricula including entrepreneurship, innovation, creativity, and leadership styles and development. Classes also explore public policy, ethics, and a host of business issues in the finance, marketing and investment areas”3. Required Courses include: 18 Credit Hours ENGR 408 Leadership Principles 2 hrs ENGR 493 Leadership Laboratory Experience 1 hrs ENGR 407 Technology-based Entrepreneurship 3 hrs ENGR 409
included exposure to clinicalmedicine and the relevant vocabulary, research experiences that emphasize the creation andapplication of new scientific knowledge, and entrepreneurial experience and its attendantvocabulary. The ten-week summer course also emphasizes development of skills in leadership,communication, ethics, and team building.The typical day for the internship students begins with ninety minutes of lectures and exercisesabout ethics, communication skills, entrepreneurship, and leadership. Students attend a full-dayhuman cadaver-based anatomy course for the first two weeks of the course. Lectures, dissection,and special projects comprise this course of instruction in the anatomy, physiology, andpathophysiology of the major organ systems
by invited speakers,focusing on teaching skills and professional development. Topics for the seminarpredominantly focused on ethics, principles of effective teaching, communication skills,grading, student/teacher interaction, intellectual property and professional licensure, etc.Speakers for the seminar consisted of professionals from within the college as well asexperts from outside the college and industry. Attendance for the seminar was voluntary.However, to encourage attendance students attending minimum of five seminars receiveda Certificate of Teaching Preparedness and Professional Development. A Guidebook forGraduate Teaching Assistants is being compiled, which consists of summary for eachseminar topic, key observations and frequently
EVALUATION OF THE IMPACT OF A SERVICE LEARNING PROJECT IN A REQUIRED FIRST-YEAR ENGINEERING COURSEAbstractIn Fall 2004, a service-learning curriculum was introduced in one section of Engineering 100:Introduction to Engineering, at the University of Michigan. Engineering 100 is a required coursefor all first year students and comprises a team project coupled with an introduction to technicalcommunication. The course also includes threads of environmental sustainability, ethics and therole of the engineer in society. As a required course, Engineering 100 has suffered from lowteaching evaluations, despite the efforts of many faculty to actively engage students in thelearning process. Thus, one of the goals of this project
consistent with criteria set forth by EngineersAustralia and ABET for engineering degree programs. Both organizations encourage arealistic understanding of professional practice, including project management and ethics, andrequire students to be able to work in multi-disciplinary groups and communicate effectively.Although universities have the entire duration of the degree program to meet theserequirements, students benefit greatly from early exposure. The purpose of this study was todiscuss best practices for introductory courses that focus on professional engineering skillsand practice. Through internet-based research, information was gathered about 82 courses atuniversities in Australia, the United States, Canada, and Great Britain. Courses that
therequirements for ABET, and would not impose unreasonable levels of additional work on thefaculty. Ultimately, this approach led to a successful outcome for all programs in their firstevaluation under EC2000.ABET-related assessment process were instrumental in identifying needed changes in many ofthe individual programs and also one major issue that cut across departments, which was theneed for more ethics related experience in the curriculum. This need was addressed through acollaborative effort between the Leonhard Center and the Doug & Julie Rock Ethics Institute inthe College of the Liberal Arts. The initial work of this partnership was stimulated byphilanthropic gifts from an Engineering alumnus whose daughter graduated from the College ofthe
requirements currently in place. Therefore, it is beneficial to examine othermechanisms for incorporating biorefinery instruction, either as individual topics, components, orunits that can be used as specific learning modules, into existing coursework. Many approacheshave been found to be quite successful vis-à-vis augmenting engineering instruction by insertingadditional materials into mainstream instruction [62]. Addressing engineering ethics is a primeexample. Some avenues that have been shown to work well include integrating focusedcomponents (theory as well as case study analyses) into specific technical courses [63-67],examining issues during technical problem solving in specific technical courses [68], issues andtopics for review during
mechanisms for incorporating biological and bioprocessing instruction, either asindividual topics, components, or units that can be used as specific learning modules, intoexisting coursework. Many approaches have been found to be quite successful vis-à-vis Page 11.1294.10augmenting engineering and technology instruction by inserting additional materials intomainstream instruction [58]. Addressing engineering ethics is a prime example. Some avenuesthat have been shown to work well include integrating focused components (theory as well ascase study analyses) into specific technical courses [59-63], examining issues during technicalproblem solving in
. A recent study by theNational Academy of Engineering reinforces these concerns by stating that “this new level ofintimacy necessitates that engineering (and engineers) develop a stronger sense of howtechnology and public policy interact.”1To bridge this gap between engineering and public policy, we developed an introductory coursefor both political science and engineering students. Components of the course included anintroduction to policy formulation, an examination of the institutions involved in public policy,the role ethics and values play in setting policy, and the examination of several specific policytopics. The course concluded with mock legislative oversight hearings. Surveys indicate that theclass was well-received by the students
there is enough here towhet the engineer’s appetite. Perhaps the biggest obstacle is that, for good reasons, we don’twant to know how much work we’re really doing.Perhaps if we assemble the proper tools we can find a way. Three tools will be necessary to start,a good model, some comfortable ethical principles and a toolbox filled with the principles ofgood old fashioned work measurement. The first step is to develop a model Page 11.696.2The Job ModelAcademia changed about half a century ago from what I shall call the “Ancient” model to theCorporate model. During the age of the Ancient model, a faculty member lived close to thecollege and was on
that graduates of the program will have experiencedkey areas of the engineering profession and demonstrated their abilities to perform in aprofessional manner. This Professional Component has been divided into Engineering Design,Professional Communications, Professional (Computer) Tools, and Ethics, with studentsreceiving instruction and practice in each area at least once per academic year.The intended transition from students as observers to graduates as competent practitioners isaccomplished by project activities demonstrating the practice of engineering over the entirecurriculum. Freshmen individually build artifacts, sophomores function in design teams, andjuniors extend the design experience to an external audience. Seniors are thus
for Engineering Education, 2006 Defining and Assessing the ABET Professional Skills Using ePortfolioWhile most engineering programs are confident developing specific criteria and assessment toolsfor the technical skills described in ABET Criterion 3a-k, the question of how to define, teachand assess the professional skills (teamwork, professional and ethical responsibility,communication, impact of engineering solutions, life-long learning, and contemporary issues)remains much more challenging. This paper describes concrete, assessable expectations thatconnect student work to professional skills, broken down by level and organized into ePortfolioassessment matrices that reflect recognized
(IPRO®) at our university provides a six credit multi-disciplinary, project team based course required of all undergraduates which helps develop inthese students various knowledge and skills deemed essential by ABET and future employers.This knowledge and skill, defined from our course Learning Objectives [LO], are competency inteamwork, communications, project management and ethical behavior, developed in the contextof addressing a real world problem. Through this research, we are assessing whether or notstudents that participate in an IPRO course gain a more thorough understanding of thedeclarative knowledge supporting comprehension of the Learning Objectives by administering aknowledge test to each IPRO student both at the beginning and at
Page 11.888.2students were getting adequate preparation using computer software such as Microsoft Office inhigh school anyway prompting them to eliminate their freshman computer course. A newtextbook10 focusing on student success was adopted along with material on ethics, workplacediversity, quality, and lifelong learning. Ethics is introduced in the course text but material fromthe free, web based American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) Professional PracticeCurriculum (PPC) was predominantly used. Workplace diversity came from the same source.Both topics have a quiz on the ASME PPC web site11 that students can take for practice. Amultiple choice test was prepared over the material, modifying some of the web questions andadding
information management (DB) information systems development intelligent systems (AI) legal/professional/ethics/society networks operating systems programming security software life cycle systems administration
having the expertise to devise improved construction or design alternatives. Page 11.236.3 • Understanding implies a thorough mental grasp and comprehension of a concept or topic. Understanding typically requires more than abstract knowledge. For example, an engineer with an understanding of professional and ethical responsibility should be able to identify and to communicate ethical issues arising from a practical case study. • Ability is a capability to perform with competence. An engineer with the ability to design a particular system can take responsibility for the system, identifying all the necessary
Page 11.1372.17 Objective #3: For EET: Uses the principles of science, mathematics, and engineering technology to design, implement, and evaluate hardware and software solutions to complex technical problems.Outcomes Ratings Evidence Weaknesses/Suggestions for (0 - 4) ImprovementSelects and defines a Proposes a problem for investigationmeaningful problem taking Identifies criteria for the proposal (taking safety,safety, ethical, social, ethical, social, economic, and technical
starting the process by orienting the first planning meeting to relevantdepartment, college, university, and accrediting agency outcomes: Department: Engineering Technology Outcomes: The department of Engineering Technology has written its student learning outcomes in five categories, A-E. The faculty/librarian team selected four outcomes that the instructor’s assignment could encompass: Ability to be life-long learners Ability to write clear and effective technical reports, proposals, and business correspondence Awareness and understanding of the impact of technology on society Ability to practice professional ethics and social responsibilityFaculty
regular meetings to discuss the progress in theirexperiments, being included in the day-to-day workings of the laboratory and are notencountering personal conflicts. These meetings are scheduled by the CDE on an individual andgroup basis.Four-Part StructureThe program was restructured to include an ethics course in 2001 when NSF fundingsupplemented the contributions from industry. The four main components of the REU are allcritical to providing participants with a balanced experience. The four components are:independent laboratory research; an ethics course; a Weekly Meeting Series; and a WeekendExcursion Series. The benefits of each activity be discussed separately as well as the synergisticeffects of these components working together. Figure 1
. Page 11.757.42005 Workshop scheduleDate/Time ActivitySunday, July 10 6:00 PM Welcome ReceptionMonday, July 11 7:30 AM Breakfast/sign in 8:15 AM Opening remarks 8:30 AM Participants Program Survey 8:45 AM Participants Introduction 9:00 AM Courses 431 & 531 (Introduction to security) 10:30 AM Break 10:45 AM Courses 530 & 532 (Network security & Information warfare) 12:00 PM Lunch 1:00 PM Computer Security Camp 1:30 PM Course 535 (Steganography) 2:00 PM Course 534 (Ethics) 2:30 PM Course 537 (Wireless Security
management discussions, briefings on CE projects, technological Page 11.231.3 advances in the discipline, cutting edge research, lessons learned through a career in CE, introductions to advanced CE software, business practices, the role of a new CE graduate in a firm, preparing for job interviews, resume writing and opportunities in the CE field.2. Hold professional conduct meetings: A special meeting category exists to promote meetings that focus on ethics and issues concerning professional licensure. Often real cases are discussed, issues engineers face in the real world on a continual basis, as well as requirements and expectations on
overhaul.During the summer of 2004, the authors rewrote the course, creating a new course that focuseson technology’s impact on society. By removing circuits and machines, the course now covers abroader range of electrical engineering fields such as image and signal processing, datacompression, electronic navigation, communications, and computer networks and security. Thecourse examines current trends; with a focus on how the Coast Guard and Homeland Securityuse technology and discusses the ethical issues that arise with the potential misuse of technology.The authors developed several innovative lesson plans, laboratories and even a series of debatesto improve the students’ understanding of technological trade-offs, while developing their
takingresponsibility for a mistake requires internal fortitude – it takes guts! Robert Furey sees humilityand pride not as much as opposites, but as necessary complements to each other: “Humility andpride compose a dialectic; each concept gives the other meaning. Without humility, pridebecomes arrogance and conceit. Without pride, humility becomes passivity and complacency.”21Personal humility is important for an engineering professional. We can find expectations forpersonal behavior related to humility in many engineering codes of ethics. For example, mostengineering codes of ethics indicate that engineers must act within their area of competence andhonestly indicate any limitations in their expertise. The Institute of Electrical and ElectronicsEngineers
. Social responsibility, v. Ethical issues, and vi. Diversity/Community values. 6. To introduce technical material not covered in coursework. Selection of Design Teams and Management. The senior class is split into independentdesign teams (typically there are 6 to 7 students per team). Teams are encouraged to operate asan engineering consulting firm. Each team is led by a project manager and a deputy projectmanager who are responsible for the deliverables. An effort is made to have at least one studentin each team from each of the specialty areas (structures, geotechnical, transportation,construction, and environmental). All students before the end of their junior year are required tocomplete an online form documenting